Book review: Warships of the USSR and Russia 1945-1995

January 2nd, 2009

From Tue Oct 07 14:15:25 1997
>Date: Tue, 07 Oct 1997 12:38:59 -0700
>From: Mike Potter
>Organization: Artecon, Inc.
>X-Mailer: Mozilla 3.01Gold (WinNT; I)
>To: mahan@microworks.net, MARHST-L@post.queensu.ca
>Subject: Book review: Warships of the USSR and Russia 1945-1995
>Precendence: bulk
>Sender: mahan-owner@microworks.net
>Reply-To: mahan@microworks.net
>
>I wrote this review for _Naval Engineers Journal_, published by the
>American Society of Naval Engineers (ASNE):
>
>Book: Alexander Sergeivich Pavlov (author) and Norman Friedman (editor),
>_Warships of the USSR and Russia 1945-1995_ [Annapolis: Naval Institute
>Press, 1997]
>
> Without access to official sources but with help from a network of
>”about 550″ fellow naval enthusiasts, in this reference handbook Russian
>naval architect Alexander Pavlov describes all Soviet and Russian
>warships launched or completed since 1945. ASNE member Dr. Norman
>Friedman, an articulate and insightful expert on modern warships,
>amplifies the translated text using western intelligence sources and
>other recent Russian publications.
> The book is arranged as were mid-century editions of _Jane’s Fighting
>Ships_, beginning with battleships and ending with auxiliaries. For a
>rough indicator of Soviet design priorities: submarines and coastal or
>inland surface ships occupy half the pages. Illustrations are large and
>plentiful. Diagrams show internal arrangements and underwater hull forms
>for submarines, information entirely hidden from the west as recently as
>1991.
> An illuminating discovery is that Soviet Russia followed ten-year
>plans for warship construction projects, which tends to confirm earlier
>estimates that the Soviet navy’s strategic mission changed very little
>from Stalin onward. I think successive Soviet regimes built this navy
>primarily to deter or defeat any potential foreign attempt to intervene
>in a Russian-controlled region should the local authorities collapse,
>and secondarily, to fight as the seaward flank should an opportunity
>arise for a Soviet military advance into the Middle East, Scandinavia,
>or wherever. The resulting fleet configuration was already suitable for
>defending ballistic missile submarine bastions when that mission was
>added around 1970.
> Pavlov reveals innovative, almost fantastic, craft such as the huge
>and heavily-armed Project 1239 surface effect ships. U.S. Navy personnel
>are impressed with the information that this book delivers but are
>somewhat disoriented by Russian weapons designations. NATO codes are
>given for ships and some missiles only.
> Exciting discoveries are offset by absences of some data. This book
>says virtually nothing about actual operations or about how
>satisfactorily seamen, naval architects, economists, and strategists
>judged these ships. How well does the aforementioned Project 1239
>perform? Poorly, say other sources; Pavlov is silent. Naval aviation and
>coast defenses are not covered. Ships’ fates are rarely stated; no doubt
>few officials even in Russia really know this dormant fleet’s true
>status today.
> _Warships of the USSR and Russia_ works primarily as an additional
>reference book for naval enthusiasts and professionals who have other
>books about these ships, their weapons, and their operations. Those
>readers may ponder whether to fault or to salute the Russians for
>actually building, at great effort in a poor nation, advanced craft of
>types that American authorities dismissed as impractical for warships.
>
>–
>Michael C. Potter, Mgr, TelCo/Govt Programs mike.potter@artecon.com
>Artecon, Inc. | | Mail: PO Box 9000
>6305 El Camino Real -|- _|_ Carlsbad CA
>Carlsbad CA 92009 >_|_( |/_>ph: 760/431-4465 >_III_ V|/ _III_ |/|_o fx: 760/931-5527
> =-| L/_| _|____L_/_|==
> ___ ________|____-===L|_LL| -==| .___ |
> ___. __I____|_[_]_______|_____[__||____[_]_|__|_=====_|\__–+====–/
>\_____/|_|__| == 963 /
>|

Posted via email from mahan’s posterous

Purpose
The Mahan Naval Discussion List hosted here at NavalStrategy.org is to foster discussion and debate on the relevance of Admiral Alfred Thayer Mahan's ideas on the importance of sea power influenced navies around the world.
Links